For a Manhattan stay, compare Margaritaville Resort Times Square’s heated rooftop pool. For a JFK stop, consider TWA Hotel’s year-round rooftop pool. The William Vale is the Brooklyn option on this shortlist, but its pool was closed for the season at our 18 November 2026 check. [NY6][NY1][NY3]
These addresses serve very different itineraries. The shortlist includes outdoor rooftop or elevated-deck pools, with each hotel identified separately. A winter operating policy is not a guarantee of access on your chosen date.
At a glance
Compare the stays
On a small screen, scroll across the comparison.
| Hotel | Where you stay | Pool and season | Admission distinction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Margaritaville Resort Times Square[NY5][NY6] | Manhattan; 560 Seventh Avenue | Sixth-floor heated rooftop pool; year-round policy | Primarily hotel guests; limited outside passes on selected dates. Confirm seasonal hours. |
| The William Vale[NY3][NY4] | Williamsburg, Brooklyn; 111 N 12th Street | Seasonal rooftop pool; currently closed | Next-season opening and access terms remain unconfirmed. |
| TWA Hotel[NY1][NY2] | JFK Airport, Queens; One Idlewild Drive | Year-round rooftop infinity pool | Different hotel-guest and outside-visitor rules; seasonal charges and reservations. |
Consider for a Manhattan itinerary
Margaritaville Resort Times Square
560 Seventh Avenue, New York, NY 10018 · Manhattan
Margaritaville puts this comparison’s Manhattan option at 560 Seventh Avenue. Its pool is on the sixth floor; the official pool page describes heating and year-round operation. [NY5][NY6]
The FAQ gives hotel guests priority, with a limited number of outside passes potentially available on selected dates. It also includes priority pool access among the resort-fee benefits. Priority does not mean a guaranteed lounger or permission for an extra visitor. [NY5]
Ask whether the available swimming hours fit your plans. A pool may add little to the stay if you will be away during its opening window. Compare the full room total and any separate seating reservation before making the pool your deciding feature.
The hotel publishes seasonal swimming hours. Confirm the schedule for your dates rather than relying on an opening time copied into an older guide.
Consider for Brooklyn after confirming the next pool season
The William Vale
111 N 12th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11249
The William Vale is at 111 N 12th Street in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. Its FAQ identifies a seasonal rooftop pool, while the dedicated pool page currently announces the end of the season. [NY3][NY4]
For a winter trip, remove swimming here from your expected activities unless the hotel gives you a new, explicit opening confirmation. For a later visit, ask for the next season’s dates and admission rules before choosing a non-refundable rate.
We have not carried forward last season’s timed-entry arrangements, age restrictions or public-pass terms. Those details can change between seasons. The property remains in this guide as a verified seasonal option, not as a recommendation for a swim today.
A room can be bookable while the pool is closed. Do not treat retained summer promotions or day-pass pages as proof of current swimming access.
Consider when JFK is part of the plan
TWA Hotel
One Idlewild Drive, JFK International Airport, New York, NY 11430-1962 · Queens
TWA Hotel’s own address is One Idlewild Drive at JFK. It is outside the airport terminals and connected to Terminal 5. Use the hotel’s specific location information when arranging arrival; this is not the William Vale address in Brooklyn. [NY2]
The rooftop pool operates year-round. Its posted chart lists no pool admission charge for hotel guests from November 1 to May 1, while outside visitors remain subject to a charge. Other seasonal reservation conditions apply, so check the chart for your actual visit. [NY1]
For a short airport stop, work backwards from the time you must return to your terminal. Allow for changing, collecting belongings and airport procedures before deciding whether a swimming reservation is practical. We have not calculated a safe layover duration for you.
Airport access and swimming admission need separate planning. A pool booking does not answer immigration eligibility, security queues or the time needed to reach your flight.
Choose Manhattan, Brooklyn or the airport first
Start with the addresses rather than the skyline photographs. A stay centred on Manhattan, a Brooklyn visit and a night before a JFK flight solve different problems. Compare the journeys you will actually make; this guide does not promise transfer times or a particular public-transport connection.
For winter swimming, the two year-round policies are the relevant starting points in this shortlist. For a later Brooklyn trip, ask William Vale for its new seasonal dates. None of these judgments ranks the hotels’ service, value or room comfort.
A pool pass is not the same as a hotel stay
Read the admission category before comparing prices. Hotel guests, day-room users, outside pool visitors and restaurant customers may have different rights. An outside pass may limit time, seating or access to other facilities; a room rate may still carry mandatory hotel fees.
At TWA, use the pool-specific chart for the visitor category. At Margaritaville, ask whether a pass is actually available for your date. William Vale’s next-season arrangements have not been established. Avoid treating a bar reservation as a swimming reservation. [NY1][NY5]
- Confirm the opening date and the swimming window, not only the bar’s opening hours.
- Check whether children and extra visitors qualify under your reservation.
- Ask whether seats, towels, changing facilities or a cabana are included or separate.
- Confirm the cancellation terms for both the hotel room and any pool purchase.
How to read the seasonal information
Margaritaville’s pool page shows more than one schedule, while its FAQ explains that hours change seasonally. We therefore give the year-round policy without printing one timetable as universally correct. Confirm the current window with the hotel. [NY5][NY6]
The sources support the facilities and policies described here. They do not establish live availability, temperatures during your visit, personal experience of the pools or a complete list of New York options. Each hotel’s own official link and address are kept with its entry so the properties cannot be mistaken for one another.
Check the details
Sources & verification
Hotel policies can change. These are the pages used for this comparison; a checked date is not a promise of availability.
- NY1TWA Hotel: rooftop pool and access chart
Year-round rooftop pool; seasonal reservation/cover-charge distinction for hotel and outside guests. Exact future prices are not guaranteed. Checked 18 November 2026.
- NY2TWA Hotel: location and visitor information
One Idlewild Drive at JFK; outside terminals, connected to Terminal 5. Airport-security and customs conditions are separate from pool entry. Checked 18 November 2026.
- NY3The William Vale: pool seasonal notice
Pool closed for the season; retained summer promotions do not establish next-season terms. Checked 18 November 2026.
- NY4The William Vale: hotel and pool FAQ
Brooklyn address and seasonal rooftop-pool classification. Checked 18 November 2026.
- NY5Margaritaville Times Square: hotel FAQ
560 Seventh Avenue; guest-priority policy, limited selected-date outside passes, resort-fee pool access and seasonal hours. Checked 18 November 2026.
- NY6Margaritaville Times Square: rooftop pool
Sixth-floor heated year-round pool. Different hours appear on the page; exact times are not repeated in this guide. Checked 18 November 2026.